Mostly solidified hardground at the top of the crystal pile in the Bushveld magma chamber

Mafic layered intrusions show abundant evidence for the formation through the progressive inwards growth of a mushy solidification layer, with a central body of nearly crystal-free resident melt. The thickness and permeability of the mushy layer play a vital role in operation of several petrogenetic processes but remain poorly constrained in layered intrusions. To address this issue, we have re-examined the cumulate sequence in the Upper and Critical Zones of the Bushveld Complex. Although some observations (e.g., soft-sediment deformation) are indicative of cumulate rocks being mushy and having experienced interstitial melt percolation (e.g., metasomatic anorthosites), other field and textural evidence suggest the contrary. Some of the clearest evidence comes from sections through chromitite and magnetitite layers as well as through the Merensky Reef, layers that were deposited on the eroded rocks of the temporary chamber floor. Below the erosional surface, the layered rocks (1) were tilted and truncated without losing their internal coherence, (2) have knife-sharp contacts with the overlying rocks, (3) show minimal evidence of penetration by downward-percolating melt, (4) reveal sharp truncation of individual crystals, particularly beheading of pyroxene oikocrysts and intersecting of polysynthetic twinning in plagioclase, and (5) show resumed growth on the truncated crystals into the overlying rocks. These observations indicate that the cumulates of the inward-growing chamber floor were almost entirely solid at the time of the erosion and deposition of these layers. To reconcile these two sets of contrasting observations, we propose that only a few metres of the uppermost portion of the cumulate pile of the Upper and Critical Zones of Bushveld magma chamber were mushy, with other underlying rocks being almost totally solidified. The mushy layer tends to be thin and locally even non-existent (e.g., in magnetitite layers) due to high efficiency of primary adcumulus growth at the crystal-liquid interface of the temporary chamber floor. The solid chamber floor results from thermochemical erosion of the entire mushy layer by magmas replenishing the evolving chamber. The study implies that such petrogenetic processes as the hydrodynamic sorting of crystals and reactive porous flow may only operate within this very thin mushy portion of the cumulate pile and cannot therefore be responsible for any large-scale petrological features (e.g., platinum reefs, massive chromitites, stratiform anorthosite layers) of the Bushveld Complex.