Detailed analysis of recurrent sites after wedge resection for primary hepatocellular carcinoma considering the potential usefulness of anatomic resection: a retrospective cohort study

Purpose We investigated the detailed recurrent sites after wedge liver resection for primary hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). Methods We retrospectively reviewed 278 patients with primary HCC who underwent curative liver resection between 2000 and 2016. Recurrent sites were divided into four groups: around the initial HCC (segmental recurrence), within the same section as the primary HCC (sectional recurrence), within the same lobe as the primary HCC (lobar recurrence), and contralateral or extrahepatic recurrence (extra recurrence). Results Recurrence was observed in 101 of 147 patients who underwent wedge resection. At first recurrence, segmental recurrence was observed in 18 patients (17.8%), while 28 patients (27.7%) were with sectional recurrence and 48 patients (47.5%) were with lobar recurrence. However, the cumulative recurrent sites of each patient showed extra recurrence in 53 patients (52.5%) at initial recurrence, 79 patients (78.2%) until the second recurrence, 89 patients (88.1%) until the third recurrence, 94 patients (93.0%) until the fourth, and 96 patients (95.0%) until the fifth recurrence. Conclusion Some intrahepatic recurrence after wedge resection might have been avoided if anatomic resection had been performed instead. However, the number of contralateral or extrahepatic recurrences increased with the number of recurrences.