“The Right to Lead”: Navajo Language, Dis‐citizenship, and Diné Presidential Politics

This article examines the 2014 Navajo Nation presidential primary election and language debate as a window into the politics of Navajo heritage language and identity. Using Facebook posts written in response to a videotaped hearing testing the fluency of one of the candidates that subsequently went viral, we analyse social citizenship and stigmatized language identities through the lens of critical Dine (Navajo) language consciousness. Focusing on generational differences between speaker groups that undergirded this debate, we analyse (a) the fluency test itself and (b) online and ethnographic responses to the fluency test. Using discourse analysis of Facebook posts of both heritage language and new Navajo speakers, we show how new speakers in particular express investment in their language and Dine cultural continuity and, through their emphasis on the heterogeneity of contemporary Dine communicative practices, offer an alternative template for ways to move forward in Dine language reclamation efforts.