The Collection And Use Of Funds From Civil Money Penalties And Fines From Nursing Homes

Purpose: This study examined federal and state civil money penalties and fines collected from nursing homes and how states used the collected funds. Design and Methods: We used a telephone survey of state officials, Freedom of Information Act requests, state Web site searches, and stakeholder interviews to describe the funds collected, the availability and the use of funds, public information about penalties and fines, and the state allocation process and policies. Results: In 2004, 43 states collected a total of $21 million from more than 3,000 federal and state penalties and fines. Forty-two states had $60.5 million in fund accounts from penalties and fines available in 2005, and 32 states spent $28 million on a wide range of projects. Fifteen states spent $17.9 million on survey and certification activities, 19 states spent $5.6 million on provider projects, 6 states spent $1.3 million on advocacy projects, and 12 states spent $2.7 million for other projects. Most states did not provide information to the public about issuing penalties and fines, have formal procedures to inform stakeholders and allocate funds, or involve stakeholder groups in the decision-making process. Implications: Funds from federal and state penalties and fines vary widely across states. These funds are a resource for improving the quality of nursing home care that needs more attention from policy makers and stakeholder groups.