Evolution of Outcomes with the Ileal Hydraulic Valve Continent Diversion: Reevaluation of the Benchekroun Catheterizable Stoma

Initial reports with limited follow-up suggested that the ileal hydraulic valve was a satisfactory approach to continent urinary diversion that was associated with acceptable early complication rates and uniform efficacy in achieving continence. We sought to evaluate the later outcomes of patients with this form of continent urinary diversion. An average extended follow-up of 5 years was available on 11 patients who had undergone ileal hydraulic valve diversion. Although only 13% of patients had complications requiring surgical revision at 18 months of follow-up, at the 5-year follow-up, 91% had developed complications requiring surgical revision. Of these, 64% entailed major revision of the urinary diversion. The most common late complication was stomal stenosis (73%); calculus formation (36%) and devagination (36%) were also common. Although in some cases, stomal stenosis was successfully managed by superficial revision with skin flaps and grafts, most cases required complete replacement of the efferent limb. Use of the devaginated or stenosed ileal hydraulic valve to construct a flap-valve efferent limb based on the Mitrofanoff principal succeeded in salvaging the continent urinary diversions in these patients. Novel forms of urinary diversion require extended follow-up for accurate assessment of their feasibility and efficacy. Attentive surveillance with surgical revision as necessary in such cases is mandatory for the preservation of continence and renal function.