Data from Tumor Antigen Epitopes Interpreted by the Immune System as Self or Abnormal-Self Differentially Affect Cancer Vaccine Responses

Epitope selection is an important consideration in the design of cancer vaccines, but factors affecting selection are not fully understood. We compared the immune responses to peptides and glycopeptides from the common human tumor antigen MUC1, a mucin that is coated with O-linked carbohydrates in its variable number of tandem repeats (VNTR) region. MUC1 expressed on tumor cells is characteristically underglycosylated, creating peptide and glycopeptide neoepitopes that are recognized by the immune system. The response to VNTR peptides is weaker in MUC1-transgenic mice (MUC1-Tg mice) than in wild-type (WT) mice, whereas the response to VNTR glycopeptides is equally strong in the two strains. Thus, glycopeptides seem to be recognized as foreign, whereas peptides, although immunogenic, are perceived as self. To explore this further, we generated MUC1 peptide– and glycopeptide–specific T-cell receptor transgenic mice and studied the function of their CD4 T cells when adoptively transferred into MUC1-Tg or WT mice. Peptide-specific T-cell precursors were not centrally deleted in MUC1-Tg mice and did not acquire a T regulatory phenotype. However, their response to the cognate peptide was reduced in MUC1-Tg mice compared with WT mice. In contrast, glycopeptide-specific CD4 T cells responded equally well in the two hosts and, when simultaneously activated, also enhanced the peptide-specific T-cell responses. Our data show that the immune system differentially recognizes various epitopes of tumor-associated antigens either as self or as foreign, and this controls the strength of antitumor immunity. This represents an important consideration for designing safe and effective cancer vaccines. Cancer Res; 70(14); 5788–96. ©2010 AACR.