Differences Between CT-Perfusion and Biphasic Contrast-enhanced CT for Detection and Characterization of Hepatocellular Carcinoma: Potential Explanations for Discrepant Cases.

AIM:To compare the diagnostic value of liver perfusion computed tomography (PCT) and biphasic contrast-enhanced CT (bpCECT) for detection and characterization of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC), and to identify potential causes for inter-modal discrepancies. PATIENTS AND METHODS:In this retrospective study, 162 cases with a total of 325 HCC-typical lesions were evaluated using both PCT and bpCECT (mean time between examinations=15 days, range=0-13 days). HCC diagnosis was performed by multi-modality imaging including lesion growth at follow-up. For PCT, a total acquisition time of 40 s (26 measurements) each 1.5 s using 80 kV and 100 mAs, as well as 50 ml iodine contrast agent (at 5 ml/s) covering the entire liver was used. Mean arterial liver perfusion (ALP), portal venous perfusion (PVP) and hepatic arterial index (HPI) for both tumor and non-involved liver parenchyma; mean blood flow, blood volume and k-trans for tumor were quantified. Tumor localization, and size were registered. bpCECT consisted of unenhanced, arterial (30-33 s delay), and portal-venous (70-75 s) phases performed using 120 kV, 200-250 mAs, thin-slice reformates (<1 mm), 100 ml contrast agent (at 3 ml/s) followed by 50 ml saline flush. Finally, we divided the results according to detection by PCT only (i.e. missed by pbCECT), and by both PCT and pbCECT. RESULTS:PCT detected 272 lesions compared to 217 with bpCECT only. HCCs in liver segments 4 and 5 were significantly better detected by PCT (p<0.005). Furthermore, PCT detected significantly smaller HCCs than did bpCECT (p<0.001). Lesions detected by both methods had significantly higher mean ALP (p=0.03) and HPI (p=0.02), and lower mean PVP (p=0.01). Tumor blood flow, blood volume and k-trans proved not to be significant for lesion detection. The mean ALP, HPI, and PVP in inconspicuous cirrhotic liver were also not significant for lesion detection. The PVP(tumor)/HPI(liver) ratio of detected lesions was significantly higher for PCT alone (p=0.04). Pretreated, still vital lesions were better detected by bpCECT. CONCLUSION:Detection of smaller HCC lesions, lesions located in liver segments 4 and 5, as well as lesions presenting lower ALP and HPI, and higher PVP(tumor)/HPI(liver) ratio was better using both methods, emphasizing the important role of PCT.