Psychological impact of recall on women with BRCA mutations undergoing MRI surveillance

Objective: The addition of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to mammography for surveillance of women with BRCA mutations significantly increases sensitivity but lowers specificity. This study aimed to examine whether MRI surveillance, and particularly recall, is associated with increased anxiety, depression, or breast cancer worry/distress. Methods: Women with BRCA mutations in an MRI surveillance study were invited to complete: Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS), Lerman's Breast Cancer Worry Scale, Breast Cancer Worry Interference Scale, and a quality of life rating at 3 time points: 1-2 weeks before (Ti), 4-6 weeks after (T2) and 6 months after their annual surveillance (13). Repeated measures analyses were performed over the 3 time points for recalled and non-recalled women. Results: 55 women (30 BRCA1, 25 BRCA2) completed study instruments at Ti and T2, and 48 at T3. Eighteen women (32%) were recalled for additional imaging. At Ti, 27 women (49%) were above HADS threshold for "possible cases" for anxiety (score >= 8). Recalled (but not non-recalled) women had a significant increase of HADS anxiety at 12 which dropped to below baseline by T3. No group differences were observed in terms of change over time in other quantitative psychological measures. Conclusions: While breast MRI surveillance did not have a detrimental psychological impact on women with a BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutation, recalling these very high-risk women for further imaging after a false positive MRI scan temporarily increased their global anxiety. (C) 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.